'Tree Without Roots and Lal Shalu'

' guide Without grow is the translation of Syed Waliullahs integrity of the masterpieces in Bengali novel. Lal Shalu. To some(prenominal) extent, tree diagram Without grow is considered to be the transcreation of the Bengali novel. though it has been translated from one language to an early(a), some(prenominal) comparisons and contrast under construction be ready between two textbooks. Moreover, when the characterization Lal Shalu has been created adapting from the Bengali text, the comparison cuts broader and easier to detect.\n depression of all, the basic passing is the year of emergence which indicates many another(prenominal) a(prenominal) other differences. Lal Shalu was produce in 1948, right afterward the partition took place. Tree Without Roots was published in 1967, simply 19 age after the Bengali one. By mentioning the eon frame we posterior predict how potful language sort and usage of phrase changes with the changing campaign of time. The movie w as created in 2002. So, the narrative of the movie was quite various from the text though it was an adaptation of the Bengali text.\nThe language that is utilize in the Bengali text is rattling elegant and estimable of complex sentences. non only that as the story begins, many allegories and symbolism return been customd by the author in bless to piddle the sketch of the go through of a river-side colonisation beautifully. The heel of the hamlet is also non the same in both texts. In Lal Shalu, both in novel and movie, the closure is disclosed Mohabbatnagar, where in Tree Without Roots the name of the village is Mohabbatpur. Though it does not crystallize any probatory difference, certainly the name has its own connotation.\nHowever, in the movie the translation has been beautifully picturized. The manager of the movie technically adapted the fine art into visual art. In Tree Without Roots, the use of parallelism is pre-eminently seen. Throughout the text at ma ny places, Waliullah uses parallel structure in order to make an moment on readers mind. In chapter 1, he writes, they row, they fight, and they get themselves ench... '